Embracing solitude: A philosophical reflection on the modern world

From the archive · First published: 2025-01-27

Our relationship with being alone is both two-sided and rather strange. Marx’s criticism of alienation points towards the damage of being cut off from our work and one another; Montaigne, meanwhile, invites us to consider the value of an inner space of our own. For me, the question is not merely how to escape a crowd, but how to feel at ease within ourselves.

Thinking about solitude has occupied writers and philosophers across different periods. Hannah Arendt’s discussions of loneliness and the loss of a shared world, alongside Marx’s account of alienated labour, make it difficult to treat isolation as a purely private problem. A person can become estranged from what they produce and from the people around them. What looks like a personal difficulty may also have a social setting.

Initially, I leaned towards that criticism. Individualism and the selfishness I associated with it seemed to obstruct the common good and turn people into machines. Part of me still strongly agrees. Perhaps that is my idealistic side. But with age, I have noticed how life wears down some of our idealism. Che Guevara, Rosa Luxemburg and Gandhi come to mind as people whose commitments shaped their lives in very different ways. Ordinary life, with its obligations and compromises, can make that degree of commitment difficult to sustain.

Solitude and modern alienation

To be honest, there is still an idealist in me. Over time, though, that idealism has collided with experience. We do not remain fixed in one direction. A change in mood or circumstance can reveal a side of an idea we had not previously seen. My relationship with solitude developed in precisely this way. I have long criticised social and economic arrangements that isolate people, and I have not entirely abandoned that criticism.

Yet being alone is not always a punishment. Fromm’s writing about love makes me think about our need for connection; solitude also offers room to understand ourselves. Both can matter. A crowded digital life can still feel lonely. Numerous contacts are not necessarily meaningful relationships, and the appearance of company does not settle the question of whether we feel understood.

Levinas offers another direction for reflection: the ethical importance of encountering another person. I read this alongside my need for solitude, rather than as an instruction to choose one and reject the other. How we make room for someone else and how we remain ourselves are connected questions.

Social life and individuality

As I said, we rarely see a subject from only one side. Some people give greater priority to individuality; others to collective life. But can anyone be entirely one or the other? A writer or thinker may emphasise one part of their position in public without that position exhausting their inner life. I am wary of reducing a person to a single label. Most lives contain contradictions and shades of grey.

As a Turkish reader, Orhan Kemal is one of the first writers who comes to mind when I think about social concern. His attention to people’s lives and to society matters deeply to me. But could we therefore claim that he always thought of others before himself? That would be reductive. Like anybody else, a writer has needs, vulnerabilities and pain. Nor can Nietzsche, often read through the lens of individualism, be contained by that one word. A philosopher’s work is larger than the label attached to it.

The side of solitude that makes peace with itself

For a while, my experience of relationships made me feel that people were bringing more harm than benefit. The Pollyanna in me kept fighting somewhere, but painful experiences taught me to protect a certain distance. Learning to enjoy solitude, and accepting that enjoying it did not automatically make me a servant of capitalism, developed alongside disappointments in relationships.

Losing friendships I had worked hard to build also made me reconsider the importance I attached to family ties. I read Nâzım Hikmet’s Kan Konuşmaz around fifteen years before writing this essay and was then persuaded that blood ties need not determine relationships. Later I questioned the issue again. Biological relatedness may matter in human behaviour, but it cannot by itself explain care, loyalty or the quality of a relationship. A novel, moreover, is not a genetic experiment; it opens a different kind of inquiry.

Bauman’s account of liquid modernity is another lens I bring to these thoughts. Relationships can feel fragile, provisional and easy to abandon. I do not read that as proof that all modern bonds are shallow. It helps me ask how we balance freedom with the continuity that trust needs.

When I found that even close relatives on my mother’s side did not necessarily offer a friendly relationship, I had to admit that the heart’s wishes were not enough. We want to follow affection, but we can hurt ourselves by ignoring what experience keeps telling us. Reason has a place here. Sometimes the wish to try again needs to listen to the history of what actually happened.

That is why I have come to embrace my solitude. When I am alone, no one is twisting my words, assuming the worst of me or answering me with insults. There are books, music and my belief in myself. Montaigne’s reflections remind me that leaving a crowd physically is not the whole task; the noise we carry within us also needs attention.

After major heartbreaks, I have often moved. Different cities, even different countries. But I learned that a change of address does not necessarily bring relief. A mind can carry its old chains into a new room. Making an inner place where I can keep myself company has become more important than simply going elsewhere.

Solitude can therefore be both painful and illuminating. For me, listening to reason in relationships and accepting the possibilities of time alone can make life more meaningful. Sartre’s famous line, ‘Hell is other people’, is not a complete account of human connection, and I do not use it as one. It touches a feeling; it does not cancel our need for kindness and company.

Perhaps making peace with ourselves requires giving up some relationships we hoped would be different. The solitude that follows can feel like a price, but sometimes it also becomes a space in which freedom begins.

My suggestion is not to turn solitude into a test or a decision to give up on people altogether. A book, a walk alone, then a brief meeting with someone you want to see: we can find a balance between personal space and connections that feel good to us.

THE PI LETTER

Pınar’ın seçtikleri, gelen kutunda.

Yeni sergiler, sahneden notlar, özenli sofralar ve bilime dair sorular. Yeni yazılardan e posta ile haberdar ol.

THE PI LETTER

Pınar’s perspective, in your inbox.

Exhibitions, notes from the stage, thoughtful food and questions for science. Receive new stories by email.

THE PI LETTER

Pınars Perspektive, in Ihrem Postfach.

Ausstellungen, Bühnennotizen, gutes Essen und Fragen an die Wissenschaft. Neue Beiträge per E Mail erhalten.