From the archive · First published: 2020-12-01

Should we live for eternal ataraxia—emotional tranquillity? Do we seek unending happiness? Do we enjoy happiness only while it is happening, or do we also enjoy remembering those fruitful moments? We can certainly experience both. But my question is not which gives us more pleasure. It is which one we are striving for.
If we are collecting a package of enthusiastic memories, we first have to create a moment that we will remember with a smile. Whether we want the experience or its memory, we still have to live it. Yet that does not quite answer my question. I am interested here in what gives an experience its meaning, rather than in a list of neurotransmitters or brain structures.
A familiar taste, a scent or a piece of music can bring back the place, the person we were with, even something of the atmosphere. We may feel moved again long after the event. This does not make memory an exact recording. Remembering reconstructs an experience, and both its details and the feelings attached to it can change.
Even when we conduct an experiment or speak in public, what stays with us may be the feeling rather than our sentences. The heartbreak, the anxiety, the tremor before a speech. The syntax disappears, while the emotional impression remains remarkably vivid. Not necessarily identical—but vivid.
When I recall giving a presentation about a plant-based diet, in German, to a German audience, I can still feel my excitement and rather excessive confidence. I remember making people laugh. I also remember feeling challenged when a man raised a question about white sugar and bovine gelatin. I cannot reproduce every sentence of that exchange. I can remember how it felt to be standing there.
It would be too simple to assign the speech to one brain region and the memory to another. Language, memory and emotion depend on interacting systems. Nor can we measure the worth of different pleasures by imagining equal quantities of a neurotransmitter. A philosopher discovering an idea, someone enjoying falafel, and someone sunbathing in the Bahamas may all be happy. Their experiences do not become interchangeable for that reason.
Still, I wonder: if we were given endless time inside one splendid moment, would it feel as intense as it does when we revisit it? Remembering can give a moment a second life. Does an experience matter if we never remember it? What does learning retain when conscious recollection is absent? These are related questions, but they are not the same question.
I find myself inclined to think that our moments acquire additional meaning when we remember and relive them. Perhaps we seek not only the joyful moment, but also the possibility of meeting it again. We quietly take for granted that there will be an afterlife for it in memory.
Yet I cannot dismiss an extraordinary experience simply because it is followed by amnesia, or because a person dies afterwards. The moment still happened. Its value need not depend on someone preserving it. A person who cannot later describe an experience may nevertheless have lived something precious. Memory is not a test of whether a life deserves meaning.
Without later recollection, a magical moment might remain bounded by its duration. With memory, it can return in another form. That return may intensify the emotion, soften it or alter its meaning. It is not always happier, and it is not always faithful. But it allows a conversation between the person we were and the person we have become.
Remembering good times can also help us through painful ones. The recollection that things have changed before may make change imaginable again. After a long night, we have seen the sun rise. That familiar rhythm does not guarantee relief, but it can offer hope. I mean this as a reflection on experience, not as a claim that any single brain structure makes life bearable or unbearable.
The memory of moments, of natural events, of feelings: perhaps this is part of what sustains us. We reach for a kind of permanence that the moment itself cannot provide. Happiness passes. Sometimes, remembering lets us spend a little longer with it.
A small suggestion: write down one detail from a good day—a sound, a sentence, a smell. Revisit it later, without expecting memory to be a perfect recording. Further reading: the APA definition of emotional memory.
