Judged Without a Word: The Social Execution of Neurodivergent Minds

Dr. Pınar Şengül, beyaz gömlek ve gül kurusu ceketle portre.

From the archive · First published: 2025-07-16

Dr Pınar Şengül · Personal archive
Dr Pınar Şengül · Personal archive

Have you ever seen someone form an absolute judgement about a person they have never spoken to? Understanding someone requires more than collecting other people’s stories. Personality may have consistent features, but relationships also contain subjective experiences. That is one reason listening carefully to both people matters in couples therapy. Listening does not automatically divide responsibility equally: responsibility for infidelity, violence or coercion belongs to the person choosing that behaviour. Trying to understand someone does not excuse the harm they cause.

So why is it that once we step outside the therapy room, we so easily jump to conclusions — especially about those who are just a little bit different from us? The purpose of this article is to advocate for those “different from us” — to raise awareness about the psychological harm and social exclusion neurodivergent individuals endure, often based on second-, third-, or even fourth-hand narratives. These are people many of us have never even spoken to — and yet we feel entitled to judge and ostracise them.

What Is Neurodivergence?

Neurodivergence is an umbrella concept used to discuss differences in how people’s minds process information. It is not itself a medical diagnosis. It should not be treated as equivalent to a specific diagnosis such as autism or ADHD, nor should we assume it will become a diagnostic category in the future.

Neurodivergent people may differ from commonly expected patterns in information processing, social communication, attention, language or sensory experience. When I think about this, I imagine music: hearing another rhythm where we expected only one. Like postmodern jazz. That is my metaphor, not a claim that all neurodivergent people think alike.

Being neurotypical does not mean having an average IQ, a particular educational level or the same social background. Neurodivergence cannot be reduced to one brain structure, hormone level or personality trait either. Strengths and support needs vary from person to person; two people with the same diagnosis may lead very different lives.

From Microaggressions to Structural Exclusion

Neurodivergent people can face discrimination in schools, workplaces and groups. Repeated ridicule or exclusion from childhood may eventually start to feel normal. Differences may involve direct communication, sensory needs or attention regulation. But it would be inaccurate to say all neurodivergent people have low inhibitory control or express emotion in the same way.

The expression ‘wearing your emotions on your sleeve’ describes showing feelings openly. Cultural expectations can influence how that openness is received. What seems unusually direct in one setting may seem ordinary in another.

Emotional expression, conversational pace and expectations of closeness can vary between communities. That does not mean a person considered passionate in one country would receive a personality disorder diagnosis in another simply because of that difference. Taking culture seriously does not mean reducing clinical assessment to national stereotypes.

What Conditions Fall Under Neurodivergence?

• Autism: May involve differences in social communication, sensory experiences, interests and routines. Asperger syndrome, previously a separate diagnosis, is now included within the autism spectrum in current classifications. Broad labels such as ‘high-functioning’ do not, by themselves, describe someone’s support needs.

            •           ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder): Challenges with impulsivity, sustained attention, and executive functioning.

            •           Dyslexia: Difficulties in reading and processing written language.

            •           Dyscalculia: Struggles with mathematical concepts and numerical reasoning.

            •           Tourette’s Syndrome: A neurodevelopmental condition involving motor and vocal tics (Robertson, 2015).

The Real Struggle: Misinterpretation and Literal Thinking

Some neurodivergent people, including some autistic people, may interpret language more directly or literally. Implied meanings or a group’s private jokes may be difficult to follow. This is not universal. Directness may be read as rudeness, while unusual vocabulary may be read as coldness or showing off. A communication difference should not immediately become a judgement of character.

As a result, in professional or academic settings, they are often labeled as cold, overly formal, or socially awkward. This leads to reputational harm — exclusion from opportunities, misunderstandings in communication, and, ultimately, loss of trust or status in competitive environments.

The pressures to conform vary between communities, institutions and countries. I am concerned with environments in which unfamiliar behaviour is quickly punished socially. It would be too simple, however, to rank whole regions as accepting or intolerant: barriers and welcoming spaces can coexist in the same society.

Some neurodivergent people who have access to education, books, languages and opportunities for development find environments that suit them better. Sometimes this search includes moving abroad. Yet even people with those resources may carry an unmet wish to belong. Success does not automatically remove the pain of exclusion. This is not the fixed story of a diagnostic group, but a reflection on how opportunities and barriers can intersect.

And what about people facing difficulties with reading, numbers or attention without access to the support they need? Their abilities cannot be ranked by diagnostic label. The question is whether institutions make room for their particular strengths and needs.

Their struggle is doubly difficult — not just because of their brain’s wiring, but because society is determined to kick them while they’re already down. Judgment, exclusion, gossip — these are their everyday realities.

Neurodivergent individuals aren’t asking for pity. They’re asking for space. In a capitalist world obsessed with uniformity and performance, making space for difference is not a favour — it’s a moral obligation. If we fail to create inclusive academic, professional, and social spaces, we will continue to lose intellectual, creative, and human potential.

We don’t need a world of one color. We need the courage to let each hue shine.

Long live the countries, institutions, and communities that embrace neurodivergent minds — not in spite of their difference, but because of it.

My suggestion: ask a person directly which communication style or working conditions help them, rather than inferring this from a diagnosis. National Autistic Society: autism and neurodiversity; NICE: individual needs of autistic adults.

THE PI LETTER

Pınar’ın seçtikleri, gelen kutunda.

Yeni sergiler, sahneden notlar, özenli sofralar ve bilime dair sorular. Yeni yazılardan e posta ile haberdar ol.

THE PI LETTER

Pınar’s perspective, in your inbox.

Exhibitions, notes from the stage, thoughtful food and questions for science. Receive new stories by email.

THE PI LETTER

Pınars Perspektive, in Ihrem Postfach.

Ausstellungen, Bühnennotizen, gutes Essen und Fragen an die Wissenschaft. Neue Beiträge per E Mail erhalten.